Roller chopping vs mowing: The impact of cutting hunting lanes

Aug 26, 2024

A common practice on intensively managed quail properties involves cutting hunting lanes, commonly referred to as “blocking the woods”. Blocking is a multi-purpose management practice aimed at reducing groundcover and improving hunter and dog access to hiding coveys of quail.

The two ways lanes are cut are with a drum roller chopper or with a mower.

Both are effective at cutting hunting lanes, but each have a different impact on the structure of groundcover and over time, the types plants that re-sprout or remain in disturbed areas.

There are pros and cons to each.

Ground disturbance is of particular importance in areas that have sensitive native groundcover. In the Red Hills, only a small fraction of this plant community remains.

In the Red Hills region, only about 24,000 acres (6% of the region) have relatively intact native (i.e. uncultivated or converted) groundcover.

Given the rarity of this plant community, biologists are tasked with recommending responsible management practices that both meet landowner objectives and protect sensitive native groundcover.

What’s the difference?

Many land managers prefer using roller choppers for grid-blocking hunting lanes due to their speed, simplicity and durability.

They are especially useful in places where it is hard to see the ground when running or there are a high frequency of stumps and large woody debris on the ground.

The large drum and long cutting blades are able to handle rough, uneven terrain and can easily knock down small brush and hardwoods.

In operation, the roller chopper will often deeply divot the ground, and can create a moderate amount of soil disturbance, which in some situations, can promote annual weeds.

However, repeated ground disturbance can progressively degrade native groundcover quality over time.

Mowing has minimal ground disturbance; as it reduces the height and structure of the above ground plant biomass without disturbing the root structure.

There are additional maintenance costs associated with using mowers over choppers but it is often preferable to keep the native groundcover intact in areas where it still exists.

Impact to habitat

In the coastal plain of the Southeast native groundcover areas are typically determined by the presence of wiregrass and other key native plants in the understory, such as running oak, goat’s rue, bracken fern, slim leaf pawpaw, etc.

These are places that have not experienced extensive amounts of ground disturbance from agriculture or intensive site preparation for pine production.

Wherever native groundcover has persisted, it is typically in an area that has had frequent fire. Native groundcover areas have the plant community composition and structure that can resemble pre-settlement conditions — but as explained above, this plant community is extremely rare.

The tolerance of disturbance varies by species, but ground disturbance associated with roller chopping or harrowing can break apart established root structures; this is especially true for wiregrass. Once these plants are removed from a site, they may never reestablish.

Hunting lanes, or blocking the woods, is done with a mower at Tall Timbers.

Significant changes in the plant community from roller chopping are often not noticeable after one pass but, repeated disturbances over many years can have cumulative detrimental effects on native groundcover.

Some of those changes include the encroachment of lower quality, offsite hardwoods, potential for invasive species to seed and the establishment of common weedy annual plants.

These new invaders can compete for sunlight and resources, and over time become more dominant.

Some of these species, such as water oak, live oak, and sweet gum, grow faster and their leaves are much less flammable than running oak, bluejack oak, sand post oak, turkey oak, blueberries and huckleberries.

Roller-chopping can also have negative effects on a variety of animals, such as pocket gophers, gopher tortoises, hog-nose snakes, pine snakes, and tiger salamanders, which live just under the soil surface.

Mowing can be a viable alternative to roller chopping for cutting hunting lanes and controlling problem brush in areas with native ground cover.

On Tall Timbers, we have not found it to impede quail management, nor has it been found to be an issue for managers of lands with these special natural areas.

A practical reason to maintain native groundcover is that it can be cheaper than managing disturbed sites and old field lands, since prescribed fire is often the only management that is needed to maintain quality native groundcover when wiregrass and other highly flammable ground cover is present.

Given the flammability of wiregrass, and other plants in this community, there is a broader prescribed fire window throughout the year within which to meet management objectives, primarily management of hardwood encroachment, which can reduce the need for herbicides and other expensive management practices.

The decision to roller chop or mow hunting lanes ultimately falls on the land manager. Both practices achieve the same goal and both practices have pros and cons. However, if you are fortunate enough to own and manage land with sensitive native groundcover, consider blocking your woods with a mower to maintain this rare and declining vegetation type.

 

About the Author
Karl Etters
A Tallahassee native, Karl has a background in journalism and an even deeper background in exploring North Florida's wild spaces. Merge the two, and he's Tall Timbers' communication coordinator. When he's not spending time with family and friends, he can be found fly fishing, hunting, biking or walking the woods looking for turkeys.
  • Recent Articles
    Tall Timbers leading the way on prescribed fire insurance

    Above: Members of the Southwest Georgia Prescribed Burn Association conduct a burn in Grady, County, Georgia Tall Timbers is directing an innovative private market solution to deliver insurance to prescribed burners. Led by the Private Lands Prescribed Fire...

    Grant will help make improvements to unique Burn Planner tool

    A lot of planning goes into a prescribed fire long before the first drip torch is lit. To safely apply this vital ecosystem tool, burn practitioners must first know what detailed parameters are best suited for each burn unit to achieve their goals while also being a...

    Butterfly conservation initiatives flutter in with the New Year

    Brian Lloyd (left) and Dave McElveen (right) posing together during one of their long-term butterfly surveys on Tall Timbers. Photo by Lisa Mills.  The new year is shaping up to be big for butterflies thanks in large part to the dedication and support of the Stoddard...

    Tall Timber researchers study dendrochronology in Africa

    Last November, I had the opportunity to participate in the African Dendrochronological FieldSchool (ADF) in Livingstone, Zambia.  I was invited to go by Tall Timbers post-doc Dr. Nicole Zampieri, who organizes and teaches at the field school, that I work closely with....

    Smoke management and air quality in Quail Country

    Tall Timbers is working with the Georgia Forestry Commission and other partners to implement “Pilot 2.0” a project to help manage smoke and improve air quality while also maintaining the use of prescribed fire in Southwest Georgia.

    Consider conservative harvest numbers for managing bobwhite

    Quail managers spend considerable effort and expense to produce populations of bobwhite. Having large areas of habitat is critical to ensure that bobwhite populations can be sustained over time. However, since most managers are producing bobwhite for hunting, careful consideration of bobwhite harvest is also important, yet sometimes neglected.

    Livingston Place hosts inaugural Tall Timbers Youth Field Trial

    Pictured above: The winners of the inaugural Tall Timbers Youth Field Trial (Photos by Chris Mathan) First Place: Rose, Harper King; Second Place: Buzz, Kira Jenkins Third Place: May, Griffin Long   Livingston Place will host the 130th the Continental Field Trial next...

    Related Articles